Notes from actually signing up

Newsletter platforms, side by side.

What each one allowed on the free plan, and what got in the way when we set it up. The cells come from our own sign-up notes (Kit's free allowance is from its public pricing page); a dash means we have not checked it yet.

Comparison table

Newsletter platforms, side by side, tried on 2026-10-20
ToolFree planPaid plan at 10k subscribersThe catchWhat we disliked
beehiiv2,500 subscribers, $0/month—Analytics only go back 30 daysAn SMS phone check before you can reach the dashboard
KitUp to 10,000 subscribers, $0/mo (per its public pricing page)—The paid plan lists unlimited visual automations and email sequences; we didn't check what Free allowsA full-screen card form for the paid plan pops up right after onboarding
MailerLite250 subscribers and 2,500 emails a month, $0—The signup form and welcome automation stay off until your sender domain is authenticatedIt asks for a postal address before you reach the dashboard

Tried on 2026-10-20, on free plans or no-card trials. A dash means we have not verified that number on the vendor's own page yet. Plans change; check before you sign up.

How we test

  1. Only free plans and trials that skip the card. We pick the free tier, or a trial with no card required, and we never type in payment details.
  2. On a test site we own. Every tool is tried on test sites we own, never on a client's site, and tools in the same category all run through one task list.
  3. If we have not tried it, the page says so. A page about a tool we have not used carries the label "Not tried yet: based on vendor docs" and only repeats what the vendor itself publishes.
  4. Nobody pays for a spot. No tool has an affiliate deal with us, so none of them can pay to be listed or to rank higher.

Is ChatGPT citing your site?

A free checker: give it your website and a few questions your readers ask, and it shows whether ChatGPT (with web search) or Perplexity cites you in the answer.

Run the free checker

Who writes this

Sam Reyes

Sam Reyes writes a small newsletter and keeps paying for the tools that run it. Here Sam signs up for those tools, tries the free plans and trials on a real test site, and writes down what they allowed and what got in the way.

More about this site

Tried the Stack has no affiliate deals right now. Every tool link goes straight to the official site, with no tracking code attached. Read the disclosure.